June 23, 2008
June 23rd, 2008Top Stories and Commentary for Monday, June 23, 2008
Experts say the exit exam is having a huge effect on dropouts. The UC-led report showed that middle school experiences and teacher quality were also major factors.By Mitchell Landsberg/Los Angeles Times
The number of students graduating from Los Angeles public schools has declined for two straight years even as enrollment in the 12th grade has been rising sharply, new state data show. The graduation slump began when California started requiring students to pass an exit exam before they could receive a diploma. The data caught educators by surprise after they were quietly posted on the state Department of Education website. Separately, new research released this week indicated that only 48% of students in the Los Angeles Unified School District graduate on time.
Editorial/New York TimesThe United States has a long and dishonorable history of dumping the least-qualified teachers into schools that serve poor and minority students. This shameful practice has persisted nationally, despite the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, which required the states to place “highly qualified” teachers in every classroom. The picture has improved significantly, however, in New York City, where state law has abolished temporary licenses for uncertified teachers, raised standards in teacher preparation programs and spawned innovative strategies for recruiting better teachers. A new study by the nonpartisan National Bureau of Economic Research shows that the teacher qualification gap between poor and well-to-do schools in New York City narrowed considerably between 2000 and 2005.
Column by Debra J. Saunders/San Francisco Chronicle1997 saw the height of the Math Wars in California. On the one side stood educrats, who advocated mushy math - or new-new math. They sought to de-emphasize math skills, such as multiplication and solving numeric equations, in favor of pushing students to write about math and how they might solve a problem. Their unofficial motto was: There is no right answer. (Even to 2 +2.) They were clever. They knew how to make it seem as if they were pushing for more rigor, as they dumbed down curricula. For example, they said they wanted to teach children algebra starting in kindergarten, which seemed rigorous, but they had expanded the definition of algebra to the point that it was meaningless.
Also Noted for Monday, June 23, 2008:
Despite falling enrollment, the district will keep building schools as a way to eliminate year-round calendars, forced busing and portable classrooms. Critics say it’s overbuilding.By Evelyn Larrubia/Los Angeles Times
San Fernando Middle School is expecting 1,600 students this fall, but officials estimate that the north Valley campus could handle 2,300. Lake Primary Center in Echo Park is expecting 160 but has room for 260. And Lincoln High School in Lincoln Heights is anticipating about 2,700 students; it has space for about 3,000. What do Los Angeles Unified School District officials plan to do with the empty space? Add to it. The district plans to build campuses that will take hundreds of students from those schools, further reducing their enrollment. By the time the building program is completed in 2012, there will be tens of thousands of empty seats at dozens of once-crowded schools, a Times analysis shows.
Why integration never came to the LAUSDColumn by Jack Schneider/LA Daily News
Zelma Henderson, the last living plaintiff from the Brown v. Board of Education desegregation suit, died last month at the age of 88. Unlike other parents involved in the case, Henderson was satisfied with the quality of all-black schools. What mattered more to her was giving children of different races a chance to learn together and understand each other. If that had ever happened in Los Angeles, the city’s public schools might look much different than they do today. In many urban areas, the process of school integration was challenging and painful. It meant taking students out of their schools, placing them with those they had learned to fear or despise, and often busing them across town to do so.
The possible recall of two board trustees is the latest skirmish in a long dispute. But alliances are shifting.By Seema Mehta, Los Angeles Times
Southern Orange County is suburbia defined, filled with rows of spacious homes, acres of manicured lawns, high-performing schools and every chain store imaginable. It’s also the unlikely breeding ground for a parental revolt that has bitterly divided the community — and claimed several victories, most notably the felony indictment of a former schools superintendent for creating "enemies lists." The next skirmish occurs Tuesday, when voters decide whether to recall two longtime board trustees in the beleaguered Capistrano Unified School District. If district critics — a collection of parents, politicians and gadflies — replace them with candidates of their own, they will win majority control of the 50,000-student district, capping a four-year struggle.
By Cheri Carlson/Ventura County StarAll middle schools in Ventura County should have a campus police officer, no more than 461 students per counselor and perimeter fencing with locking gates to improve student safety, according to a new report by the Ventura County Grand Jury. School safety was one of several issues the Grand Jury took up this year. Jurors chose to focus on middle schools since a high school review was completed several years ago. That 2002 investigation was prompted by a rash of incidents, including a police shooting of a teenager who held a student at gunpoint at Hueneme High School in Oxnard and shootings at Columbine High School in Colorado.
Phil Holmes has taught English for decades, first to the privileged but lately to the disadvantaged. His method and his intensity make a solid connection with both extremes.By Mitchell Landsberg/Los Angeles Times
Phil Holmes, one of the great English teachers of his generation, is standing before a class of high school seniors, trampling all over their self-esteem. It is a Thursday in October, not long into the school year. Holmes gazes out at his class, his proper prep school face set off by white hair and rimless spectacles, and tells his students, all of them black kids from South Los Angeles, that the first grading period is ending "and most of you will be getting Fs." The students stare, dead silent. For perhaps the first time today, he has their full attention "This is not a good start," Holmes continues, his tone stern but even. "But on the other hand, it’s not unusual."
Commentary by Leroy Johnson/New America MediaEditor’s Note: Mississippi is taking steps to improve its dismal graduation rates, which is crucial for the success of its families writes Leroy Johnson. Johnson is the executive director of Southern Echo, a statewide leadership education, training and development organization based in Jackson. He moderated a town hall meeting in Greenville in May, part of the national Equal Voice for America’s Families Campaign.
As a parent, I’ve experienced the frustration of trying to get my children prepared for college. My son had no certified science or math teachers in high school. We sent him to a math summer camp and got him tutoring, and now he’s doing fine in college. But why did I have to pay out of pocket for educational services I had already paid for with my taxes?
Debate on whether teaching credentials are needed reopensBy Howard Mintz/San Jose Mercury News
With the battle lines drawn, a state appeals court in Los Angeles today will once again consider a controversial case that could drastically affect the growing home-school movement in California. The 2nd District Court of Appeal will hear arguments in a legal fight over whether parents who home-school their children must have teaching credentials. The same appeals court earlier this year sent shock waves through the nation’s home-schooling movement, finding that parents who lack teaching credentials are violating California’s compulsory-education laws if they home-school their children. No other state has that requirement.